Finding Your Perfect Caribbean Island – Part 3

(425 Reviews)
99% Recommended

Pam MacIntyre

Maple Grove, MN
Australia & New Zealand Specialist

New Zealand

In all my years as a Travel Professional, I’ve asked countless people, “What’s on your must-see list?” And without fail, New Zealand is always at the top! Honestly, who wouldn’t want to experience this majestic ...

To Access These Islands, You’ll Either Change Planes or Catch a Less Frequent Direct Flight


If you don’t mind a little extra travel time, these islands are absolutely worth the journey. Each one brings something unique—lush hiking trails, luxury resorts, quiet charm, or unforgettable beaches. Here are some lesser-visited gems that deserve a spot on your radar:


Martinique


If you're looking for more than just a beach bum experience, Martinique might be the island for you. Nearly half the island is forested with National Parks and protected land—making it a hiker’s haven. Beyond nature, you’ll find everything from Parisian fashion to local spice markets. Add in incredible beaches and a rich cultural mix, and you’ve got an island that truly stands out.


St. Barthelemy (St. Barts)


A celebrity hotspot with luxury at every turn, St. Barts is stunning. The photo-worthy beaches and upscale French-Caribbean cuisine make it unforgettable. Want a little nightlife? Don’t miss Nikki Beach. Best time to visit is May and June for ideal weather. It’s definitely pricey—but those who go rarely regret it.


St. Vincent & the Grenadines


Adventurers, take note—hike La Soufrière volcano, explore waterfalls like Falls of Baleine and Dark View Falls, or birdwatch along the Vermont Nature Trail. Looking for something eerie and fascinating? Check out the bat cave in Buccament Bay. And if you’re like me, a black sand beach might be just your vibe—some of the best in the Caribbean are right here.


St. Kitts & Nevis


Having been here myself, I can say these islands are stunning. While established for tourism, they don’t feel overbuilt—giving you that authentic Caribbean feel. It’s more affordable than many Southern Caribbean spots, and the locals are genuinely warm and welcoming. Nevis especially offers peaceful seclusion—and yes, more monkeys than people! Great for couples or families alike.


St. Lucia


Another personal favorite of mine—what I like to call “The Hawaii of the Caribbean.” With its lush mountains and tropical beauty, it’s an island that truly takes your breath away. It’s home to the world’s only drive-in volcano (Sulphur Springs) and the lively Gros Islet street party every Friday—such a fun local experience! The weather is mostly sunny year-round, and the accommodations are unforgettable. Think open-air, three-walled suites at places like Jade Mountain, Anse Chastanet, and Ladera. Just stunning.


Turks & Caicos


Known for their powder-soft white sand beaches (with just a hint of pink) and calm, crystal-clear waters, these islands are a dream. Grace Bay is regularly ranked among the world’s best beaches—and they’re generally free of noticeable amounts of seaweed, which makes the shoreline even more inviting. The snorkeling and diving here are next-level, thanks to the third-largest barrier reef in the world. Want to mix it up? Feed iguanas on Iguana Island or splurge on a private island stay at COMO Parrot Cay. It’s not the spot for all-inclusives, but foodies will be in heaven with the amazing restaurant scene. English is spoken, and they use the U.S. dollar—super easy for travelers.


Hurricanes Irma & Maria - 2017 Impact


Islands like Puerto Rico, St. Martin/Sint Maarten, Anguilla, Dominica, the U.S. Virgin Islands, and Barbuda were heavily impacted by Hurricanes Irma and Maria. Many are well on their way to recovery—some more than others. If you’re curious about any of these, I’d be happy to talk through where things stand. Visiting these places doesn’t just support their recovery—it gives you a deeper appreciation of the power and resilience of island life.


Which Island Is Calling You?


If any of these destinations spark your curiosity, let’s chat and figure out which one’s the perfect fit for your next adventure.

See more travel stories
Return to my Expert in Caribbean, Mexico, Belize & Costa Rica page
©  Travel Leaders Group